The Pufendorf principles
Over the past 15 years, we have welcomed hundreds of interdisciplinary research groups. Our experience is that the most interesting questions often emerge in the spaces in between, where bodies of knowledge and traditional academic disciplines meet.
Since 2009, the Pufendorf Institute has been guided by three core principles.
The bottom-up principle
The Pufendorf Institute has never issued targeted calls. Researchers choose their own topics, define their own goals and build the group they believe is best suited to tackling the scientific questions at hand, together.
The no expected deliverables principle
Perhaps the Institute's most popular principle. Groups working at the Pufendorf IAS commit themselves to exploring ideas and pursuing shared goals, but without any requirement to produce specific research outputs or submit applications for external funding.
The open space and framework principle
The Pufendorf Institute is intended to be an oasis, not only physically, but intellectually as well. Research groups are free to organise and structure their work in ways that allow ideas to take shape and evolve. Every member is expected to contribute actively. Constructive friction is nothing to fear. If anything, it is worth leaning into.
So, is the incubator on?
Freedom. No deliverables. Openness, curiosity and an inspiring environment. It certainly sounds appealing. But does it actually work?
Someone has, in fact, done the maths. As part of an evaluation carried out in 2022, Themes that had participated in the Institute between 2018 and 2021 were followed up. Researchers from those Themes went on to attract external funding amounting to 17 times the original investment made by Lund University when it awarded them a Theme at the Pufendorf Institute.
Seventeen times. If money is the only measure, the growth rate looks rather impressive.
Another way of recognising a successful incubator
There are, however, other ways of knowing whether it works.
A recent article, Building Bridges Across Disciplines: Perspectives on Interdisciplinary Coastal Research, may appear to be about interdisciplinary approaches to research on coastlines and erosion. And it is, but: Two of its authors, Caroline Hallin and Åsa Knaggård, are former members of a Pufendorf Theme. They first encountered each other's perspectives through the Theme Coastal Perspectives at Pufendorf IAS. A few years later, experiences from that collaboration have found their way into an article about what it actually takes for interdisciplinary research group to succeed.
About the Pufendorf Theme: Coastal Perspectives (Lund University research portal)
Their argument is that it is not enough to place researchers from different disciplines in the same room and hope for magic. Researchers need to be firmly grounded in their own disciplines while also being willing to learn enough about others to meet on common ground - building the "right bridges". That requires time, trust and a willingness to be challenged.
The article offers practical insights into how successful interdisciplinary research groups are built. Spoiler alert: it is quite literally about what kind of bridge you should build.
Another co-writer of the article is Sierd de Vries, fomer International Fellow to the Pufendorf Theme Coastal Perspectives.
Information about Sierd de Vries on Delft University of Technologys website
It keeps growing
But the experience lives on in more than just a published article. Every year, Caroline Hallin returns to Pufendorf Academy to talk to early-career researchers about how interdisciplinary teams actually work. Åsa Knaggård contributes to the same programme through a workshop on communicating interdisciplinary research.
Former Theme members return to Pufendorf IAS, bring what they have learned and pass it on to the next generation of curious researchers. Perhaps this is one of the finest indicators that an incubator is doing its job: experiences, ideas and collaborations continue to grow long after a group's time at the Institute has come to an end.
More reading
What is the International Fellows Programme?
Caroline Hallin and Sierd de Vries continue working in the HARCCA - project H(otspot Resilience: Co-Construct Approaches to Coastal Climate Adaptation). The project just got funded by the EU:10 million Euros.
Project to investigate future of Europe’s sandy beaches (Lund University website)